EU governments pursued additional privacy safeguards to ensure people’s payment habits are kept under wraps as part of a legislative framework for minting a virtual extension of euro banknotes and coins.
The Council of the EU rubberstamped its negotiating position for a digital euro on Friday afternoon after clinching a deal earlier this week, as reported by POLITICO. The onus is now on members of the European Parliament to agree on a legal text so that both sides can begin legislative negotiations next year.
The digital euro was the European Central Bank’s answer to Meta's (failed) plan to launch its own virtual currency, called Diem, for its 3 billion users. Since Diem's demise, ECB policymakers have pitched the project as a vital strategy to reduce the bloc’s reliance on U.S. credit card giants, Mastercard and Visa, for cross-border payments. EU shoppers would be able to pay with the virtual currency, backed by the central bank, across the bloc in the form of plastic or a smartphone app.
The spread of Big Brother-style conspiracy theories, meanwhile, has forced policymakers to take extra precautions to reassure the public that authorities will not use the digital euro to snoop on people’s payment habits.
“You cannot disregard” the concern of “many millions of citizens,” Fernando Navarrete, the center-right MEP shepherding the bill through the Parliament, told POLITICO in November. “In China, it’s explicit that they wanted to build [a digital yuan] in order to increase control over the people. I'm scared of this.”
Navarrete, who hails from the European People’s Party, is highly skeptical of the initiative but is comfortable with the notion of an offline version of the digital euro that protects people’s privacy. “I'm not saying it will be used” for snooping, “but they know that the technology has potential,” he said.
On the contrary, consumer groups have praised the initiative, assuming the digital euro is safe, free, and private. Banks are far less enthusiastic. Especially, as they'll be on the hook for distributing basic digital euro services to their clients at no extra cost — a bill that could amount to over €5 billion over four years, according to ECB estimates.
Bankers' protests aside, the biggest obstacle facing the digital euro is countering conspiracy theories that the authorities will use the ECB's project to control the populace — despite reassurances from the European Commission and the ECB.
The Commission’s original proposal and the ECB's envisioned design for the project already prevent the central bank from matching people’s digital euro accounts with citizens’ personal data.
That wasn't enough for some countries, in particular Belgium and the Netherlands, which fear the project could be politically weaponized. The final text has even strengthened privacy safeguards, making it explicit that central banks “shall not be in a position to lift these [segregation] measures during any processing of the data.”
Mindful of the crucial role that banks will play in getting digital euros into citizens’ virtual wallets, EU governments have tried to make the project more palatable for the industry. The key to pleasing bankers is ensuring they make money from the initiative.
Once the digital euro is minted, banks can charge shopkeepers a fee for processing transactions at the cashier. These fees would be capped at the average cost of international and domestic debit cards for at least five years until the overall cost of distributing the digital euro becomes more stable. Then, new fees can be calculated. The bankers aren’t convinced, however.
The Council's bid to get banks “a ‘fair’ remuneration,” while making digital euro payments “cheaper for merchants and consumers,” is a 'squaring the circle problem' [that] cannot be solved," Tobias Tenner, head of digital finance at the German banks association, said. “At least if one takes the huge necessary investments [for banks] into account.”
Curated by Shiv Shakti Mishra
