UN Climate Talks Conclude Without Fossil Fuel Commitment
Belém, Brazil – The COP30 climate summit in Belém concluded with a deal that fell short of securing new, binding promises to phase out fossil fuels. The outcome has been met with disappointment by many nations advocating for more aggressive climate action.
More than 80 countries, including the UK and EU member states, had hoped the meeting would produce a firm commitment to accelerate the reduction of oil, coal, and gas usage globally. However, resistance from oil-producing nations, arguing for their right to utilize fossil fuel resources for economic development, stymied these efforts.
The summit occurred against a backdrop of increasing concern that global efforts to limit temperature rise to 1.5C above pre-industrial levels, as outlined in the Paris Agreement, are failing.
Colombia's Climate Delegate, Daniela Durán González, expressed strong criticism of the COP presidency, alleging that countries were prevented from formally objecting to the agreement during the final plenary session. "Colombia believes that we have sufficient scientific evidence saying that more than 75% of the global greenhouse gas emissions come from fossil fuels," she stated to BBC News, emphasizing the need for the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change to address this reality.
The final agreement, dubbed the Mutirão, encourages countries to "voluntarily" accelerate their actions to reduce fossil fuel consumption.
US Absence and Negotiating Dynamics
Notably absent from the talks was a US delegation, following President Donald Trump's decision to withdraw the country from the Paris Agreement in 2015. Veteran negotiator Jennifer Morgan, former German climate envoy, described the US absence as a "hole" in the negotiations. She highlighted that the US often supports blocs like the EU and UK, and its absence was felt during crucial overnight negotiations with strong pushback from oil-producing countries.
Despite the setbacks, some countries expressed relief that the talks did not collapse or result in a regression from previous climate agreements. Antigua and Barbuda's Climate Ambassador, Ruleta Thomas, stated, "We are happy that there is a process that continues to function [...] where every country can be heard."
A representative from Saudi Arabia emphasized the importance of allowing each state to determine its own path based on its specific circumstances and economies, echoing the sentiment of many oil-producing nations.
Challenges and Disruptions at COP30
The two-week conference faced numerous logistical challenges. These ranged from sanitation issues and severe thunderstorms causing flooding, to uncomfortable conditions within the venue itself. Security was breached on multiple occasions, including a protest by around 150 individuals carrying signs against the commercialization of forests, and a fire that damaged the roof.
Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva chose Belém as the host city to highlight the importance of the Amazon rainforest and attract financial investments to the region. However, Brazil faced criticism regarding its plans to expand offshore oil and gas production near the mouth of the Amazon.
Competing Interests and Outcomes
National interests and varying vulnerabilities to climate change impacts led to diverging perspectives among participating countries. India praised the agreement as "meaningful," while a coalition representing 39 small island and low-lying coastal states deemed it "imperfect" but a step in the right direction.
Poorer nations secured promises of increased climate finance to support adaptation efforts. Sierra Leone's Minister of Environment and Climate Change, Jiwoh Abdulai, noted, "It has moved the needle. There is a clearer recognition that those with historic responsibility [countries that emitted more planet-warming gases in the past] have specific duties on climate finance."
UK Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change Ed Miliband and EU climate commissioner Wopke Hoekstra acknowledged that a more ambitious agreement would have been preferred.
Brazil also launched a new fund called the Tropical Forests Forever Facility aimed at incentivizing tropical forest conservation. The fund raised at least $6.5bn from governments by the end of the meeting. Over 90 countries endorsed a call for a global deforestation action plan.
Additional reporting by Tom Ingham, BBC climate team
Sign up for our Future Earth newsletter to get exclusive insight on the latest climate and environment news from the BBC's Climate Editor Justin Rowlatt, delivered to your inbox every week. Outside the UK? Sign up to our international newsletter here.
